Director Jan Komasa’s film Anniversary (2025) depicts a contemporary America that over a five-year period slides from a democracy where prosperity and free speech prevails to an authoritarian takeover by the “Change” movement that advocates for a one-party system, anti-democratic reform, and a crackdown on citizens' rights.
The narrative follows the middle-class Taylor family: Ellen (Diane Lane), a liberal-leaning Georgetown politics professor; her husband, Paul (Kyle Chandler), who owns a successful local restaurant; and their four children: Cynthia (Zoey Deutch), an environmental lawyer who is married to Rob (Daryl McCormack); Anna (Madeline Brewer), a lesbian stand-up comic; Josh (Dylan O'Brien), an unsuccessful novelist who is in a relationship with Liz (Phoebe Dynevor), a former student of Ellen’s; and the teenage Birdie (Mckenna Grace), a budding environmental scientist.
The film takes place around a number of family get-togethers that occur over the course of five years, bookmarked by Paul and Ellen’s loved up and happy 25th wedding anniversary, and ending with their 30th anniversary that takes place under the full weight of the Change regime’s power grab. In the intervening years, the family are torn apart by Liz’s involvement as the founder and intellectual leader of the Change movement as well as the author of its hugely popular manifesto.
There is a musical number that plays at both the 25th and the 30th anniversary get-togethers that appears to offer insight into the family dynamic, as well as the wider implications on the nation as the Change movement grows in influence and power.
We first hear Crowded House’s 1986 song “Don’t Dream It’s Over” as Ellen and Paul share a dance after their 25th anniversary party has wrapped up. While the kids are at the nearby lake getting stoned and night swimming, the two share a tipsy and flirtatious dance in the living room of their lavish house. It is clearly a song that carries deep sentimental meaning. Ellen cuts out of the dance to get a shower and leaves Paul grooving alone to the song.
Although the gentle melodies and soaring vocal delivery reflect a song that appears steeped in affection, it is in reality a break-up song. The songwriter, Neil Finn, still clings on to a relationship that has fallen apart, but it takes solace in the memories it created and how the eventual “liberation and release” from the relationship contributes to resilience and endurance going forward. It remains a song of quiet hope for the author and the listener.
However, tucked away within the song’s lyrics are the warnings for the Taylor family that “There's a battle ahead” and that “many battles are lost.” At this first airing of the song, loved up and drunk, Ellen and Paul cannot see what those battles could be. Life feels too blissful. This is commented on by Paul during the main festivities as he toasts a “great life” toward his wife and kids. They, for the time being, cannot dream that any of this could be over— or that the “wall between us” that Finn evokes could be a dividing line drawn between the family and the nation itself.
But there is an ignorance to the Taylor family. For example, the lyrics “In the paper today, tales of war and of waste” echoes the reported political stirrings within the nation and the notion that they simply know better. Because Ellen and Paul are still clinging to the coattails of normality, they—metaphorically at least— “turn right over to the TV page.” In other words, they turn a blind eye to the shifting political reality, feeling that it will fizzle out and fail.
This notion is revealed after Ellen’s realization that Liz was once a past student of hers but was ejected from the university due to her extremist views. Paul nonchalantly reassures her that “it’s not gonna last.” In this case he is referring to Josh and Liz’s early courtship, but in essence, he is also believing that the political upheaval that Liz proposes in her manifesto will also not prevail.
We are left mostly in the dark about who is leading the new political movement once it gains power. The shady Cumberland Corporation, which funds Liz’s manifesto is basically a Heritage Foundation-style think tank that, once in power, turns America into a corporatocracy. We are not made aware of the policies implemented, other than the draconian surveillance operations. There is no hint as to how society has shifted itself towards allowing totalitarianism, or even if an opposition exists. One thing we are aware of is a growing intolerance for those who wish to remain “non changers” and this is bluntly illustrated by the disappearance of Anna after a stand-up show in which she criticizes the new regime. The audience turns on her and she is forced to flee.
When the story moves outside of the Taylors’ home, we see mostly empty and immaculate spaces and streets. A few flag flies outside people’s homes—a stars and stripes with the stars portion centered. Those that don’t have these flags flying, such as the Taylors, are targets for vandalism, abuse and intense scrutiny.
We witness the changes in the nation from the perspective of the Taylor family. They are devastating, and one can assume the scenario plays out across the country. Ellen is eventually fired from Georgetown and put on a watchlist of subversives. Paul’s association with Ellen and his wayward daughter, Anna, means that people stop eating at his restaurant. It falls into receivership. Anna is hounded into exile. Birdie becomes a terrorist. Cynthia breaks up from the Change-curious Rob and returns to Ellen and Paul’s house, where she lies around all day dosing herself on antidepressants and sleeping pills. The outside influences tear the family to shreds.
The biggest metamorphosis is Josh’s. Within the five years, he goes from a bumbling wannabe novelist to a hardliner fascist. He is a zealot of the Change movement, even seemingly more so than Liz who admits to Ellen that she is scared of what he’s become and the extremities of what he believes. His whole attire, attitude, and mannerisms change, and he becomes increasingly hostile to the rest of his family at the various family events during the five-year period.
By the time we hear “Don’t Dream It’s Over” again, it is at Paul and Ellen’s 30th anniversary. The couple once again dance to the song—or perhaps more fittingly, they are forced to dance to the song by an impudent Josh. The carefree and flirtatious dance from five years previously is replaced by a sad and humiliating strut that is cut short by the arrival of Anna, disguised in a clown outfit.
In this scene, the song’s energy and its lyrics take a tonal shift from quiet hope to utter defeatism. The “dream” of a great life is over, and the “freedom within” (that of the individual) and the “freedom without” (that of the nation) has been quashed by a quasi-fascist state. An anthem of hope has been rendered into one of hopelessness just by the new environment in which it is broadcast in.
There is no rosy outcome for the family, nor for the nation at large. The Change movement prevails with its iron grip with very little public resistance. The Taylor family is destroyed by clinging to the “dream” of what once was and pretending that the “battles ahead” were not worth fighting until they were already lost.
In the final scene, Anna is chased and shot by regime police. Birdie instigates a suicide bombing at a nearby government campus. The event is broadcast live on TV for everyone to witness. Cynthia stabs Josh for his betrayal and is then gunned down. Ellen and Paul are arrested. Cloth sacks are placed over their heads and they are taken away. Liz denounces the bleeding Josh and informs the cops that he is with the offending family. Perhaps this was her plan all along.
As the house empties of activity, Liz looks at an old photo on the wall of the Taylor family in happier times. She smiles to herself. She has destroyed the family and all it believed in, and all it took was the destruction of a nation to achieve it.
Anniversary mirrors the autocratic grip that America is experiencing under the Trump administration. The Change movement is seemingly a more polite version of Make America Great Again (MAGA), but its tendencies and desired outcomes are similar, especially when concerning doubters, critics, or outright naysayers of the movements.
While some criticism could be aimed at the film for not commenting more explicitly on what is occurring on a national level (the way Alex Garland’s 2024 film Civil War did), the power of the film lies in how one family can symbolize the nation’s rupture. After all, most families across America have had similar ideological conflicts with Trump-, Republican-, or nationalist- supporting relatives. The experience is real for millions and has led to many family breakdowns. The polarization is only amplified and implemented by a government, but the ruminations often begin at the dinner table.
While the Taylor family should have listened closer to the lyrical theme of “Don’t Dream It’s Over” to garner the meaning of their own eventual downfall, we as an audience should heed the warning presented within Anniversary. It reveals a nation too easily swayed towards an authoritarian takeover. The Trump administration—the first, but most prominently the second one—is a masterclass in how governing bodies (senates, congress), institutions, businesses, representatives, and the citizenry itself can roll over and allow the whims of dictatorship to come to fruition. Anniversary reveals that the dream of democracy can be over at any time and life can become a nightmare seemingly overnight.
Director: Jan Komasa
Cast: Diane Lane, Kyle Chandler, Zoey Deutch
Writer: Lori Rosene-Gambino
Producers: Nick Wechsler, Paula Mae Schwartz, Kate Churchill, Steve Schwartz, David McLoughlin, Roger Schwartz
Editor: Michael Czarnecki
Cinematography: Piotr Sobociński Jr.
Composers: Danny Bensi, Saunder Jurriaans